Home / Banks / Comparison

BNY Mellon vs Citibank

Side-by-side credit pricing comparison from Pillar 3 disclosures.

Last updated: March 2026 · Data source: public Pillar 3 disclosures
Verdict:

On a representative BBB+ EUR 25M 5-year term loan, BNY Mellon is the cheaper lender by 10bp in minimum spread. For a EUR 25M facility, that's EUR 23,958 per year.

Bank profiles compared

Metric BNY Mellon
United States		 Citibank
United States
IRB approachA-IRBA-IRB
Cost-to-income68.0%65.0%
Effective tax rate24.0%24.0%
Avg corporate PD0.21%1.21%
Avg LGD unsecured31.3%36.6%
Avg LGD secured20.0%20.0%
Funding spread (bp)10bp15bp
Corporate EADEUR 391bnEUR 1301bn

Sample RAROC: BBB+ EUR 25M 5Y term loan

Both banks priced on the exact same deal — 150bp spread, 20bp commitment fee, 60-month maturity. Higher RAROC means the bank earns more from this deal. Lower min-spread means the borrower gets a better rate.

Component BNY Mellon Citibank
Annual revenueEUR 385,000EUR 385,000
Operating costEUR 154,000EUR 154,000
Expected lossEUR 28,750EUR 28,750
Capital required (FPE)EUR 2,451,320EUR 2,451,320
RAROC (after tax)7.85%7.40%
Min spread for 12% RAROC239bp249bp
This is just one sample deal.

Your actual portfolio has different ratings, sizes, maturities, and collateral. The cheapest bank for one deal isn't always cheapest for another. Upload your real facilities and OpenRAROC will run the same calculation on each, against BNY Mellon, Citibank, and 57 other banks.

Compare your portfolio

Read more

BNY Mellon full profile Citibank full profile All banks RAROC methodology

FAQ: BNY Mellon vs Citibank

Which bank is cheaper on corporate credit: BNY Mellon or Citibank?
On a BBB+ EUR 25M 5-year term loan, BNY Mellon requires a minimum spread of 239bp to reach a 12% RAROC hurdle, versus 249bp at the other bank — a difference of 10bp on the same deal.
How do BNY Mellon and Citibank compare on corporate PD?
BNY Mellon reports an EAD-weighted corporate PD of 0.21%, while Citibank reports 1.21%. The gap reflects differences in obligor mix and geography rather than underwriting quality.
How do the two banks differ on IRB approach?
BNY Mellon uses A-IRB and Citibank uses A-IRB. The IRB approach determines whether internal LGD models or supervisory LGDs apply, which materially affects capital required on every corporate facility.
What deal is used in this comparison?
A single standardised facility: BBB+ rated, EUR 25M drawn on a EUR 30M commitment, 5-year tenor, 150bp spread, 20bp commitment fee. Both banks are priced on this exact deal using their own disclosed Pillar 3 parameters.